A shining star of wonderful gorgeousness

English Mum’s Book(ish) Club: our September book

I think it might be me.  Maybe I’m just not cut out to run a book club?  Our September book, Rebecca’s Tale by Sally Beauman, is still sitting upon my bedside table, 1/4 read.  In the meantime I’ve read approximately five thrillers, a book about the history of British food (Taste: The Story of Britain Through its Cooking, by Kate Colquhoun), reread one of my favourite ever travel/foodie books: Under the Tuscan Sun by Frances Mayes, started Hotel Pastis by Peter Mayle,  and am currently devouring Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay (brilliant).  And all the time Rebecca’s Tale sits quietly by me, ignored.  And I loved Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier as well.  I don’t know, these days there’s just something about a book with blood and murders and forensic teams and autopsies that  floats my boat.  This one seemed, well, a bit lame.  I know.  I can’t help it.

It’s not that I don’t WANT to read it, it’s just that the first bit bored the bloody pants off me, and now I can’t even review it properly as I just can’t force myself to pick it up.  So, huge and sucky apologies to everyone, but I’m afraid I hated it.  Anyone else have any thoughts?

banner ad

17 Responses to “English Mum’s Book(ish) Club: our September book”

  1. Mum says:

    I didn’t hate it, and did finish it, but it wasn’t easy going and a bit muddling with different people telling their version of approximately the same story…not exactly ‘as compelling as the original’ which is how is was described in one review…

  2. English Mum says:

    Ma: You did better than me, then. I found the first bit (told by Col Julyan, I think) SO dismal. Listening to some silly old boy wittering on was more than I could bear x

  3. Cortes says:

    Can’t say I have read this one, and I honestly do not think I could belong to a book club, as I tend to fix on one author and read everything he or she has written. I completely agree with your current love of detective novels though.

    I recently worked my way through Ian Rankin, and was then introduced to Peter Robinson by DBM. She left me 12 of his novels before leaving on her journey, and I have managed to plow right through 8 of them already. I suppose I will have to find a new author, and buy them all to read and then pass on to DBM when she returns.

    Any suggestions?

  4. jennynib says:

    I REALLY liked it!

    Typing on phone so can’t write an essay…

    First bit was a bit Old Farty but it roared after that!

    (won’t recommend anything again Missus, sorry!!)

  5. English Mum says:

    Cortes: Ian Rankin is AMAZING – I think I’ve read them all although I’m not sure as I forget (bit of an advantage as I can read the same book twice!). Oooh, where do I begin:

    Kathy Reichs, obviously
    Val McDermid (serious blood and guts there)
    Karin Slaughter – brilliantly crafted
    James Patterson
    Nicci French
    PJ Tracey
    Mark Billingham – awesomely good

    Oh, and you must try and get some Peter James novels. Very, very good. Also my Ma just leant me Grave Doubts by Elizabeth Corley which was very good.

  6. English Mum says:

    Jen: I think you’re right though, you need to persevere with these things before you can really comment. And of course you must recommend more, otherwise how will I ever educate myself? Hmm? x

  7. Baino says:

    My first book club meeting is next week and I’m still only 1/4 of the way through Rose Tremain’s ‘The Way Home’ . . similarly boring so far but I’ll crack on with it this weekend, maybe something will happen half way through!

  8. English Mum says:

    Baino: Yeh, that’s the trouble, I’m terrible at pushing myself to read a book if I’m not into it. That Resurrectionist nearly killed me. I think I’ll avoid the Rose Tremain one then!

  9. Sandra in Maryland says:

    Funniest book club review I’ve read in a while, EM! I LOVE books about food, so Taste will definitely be on my list. New job sounds great, just your thing -congratulations!

  10. Jay says:

    I tried! I really did!! I popped into town to get it and Waterstones didn’t have it. Next time I went into town, I tried the other Waterstones, and since then I’ve looked in every darned shop that sells books in this city, it seems. Even all the charity shops in case someone had thrown it out already!

    And all through September I’ve been telling myself, ‘it’s too late to order it from eBay, I can go into (insert name of bookshop or charity shop or village or local town) and just pick it up’ only of course it didn’t ever happen. I should have ordered it right at the beginning. *Sigh*

    I even went to the library and the only copy they had was audio, so I grabbed it and ran, only to find out when I got home that it’s cassette tapes!! Needless to say, we don’t have a player, not even in the car.

    Sorry. I’m a failure as a book club member, aren’t I?

  11. Tara says:

    Agree entirely. Dull and boring.

    Just got a new one with a good review in City Paper…When The White House Was Ours by Porter Shreve. Looks more like my style. And for the record, I’m still voting for A Free Range Childhood for the next one, if you still have it in you to run the club. x

  12. Roy says:

    If it ain’t on an audiobook and MANLY I ain’t playing

  13. wee jen says:

    Um, *shuffle, shuffle, looks at feet, coughs* I didn’t read it. Totally forgot! Know what it’s like to get caught up with other books though. I’ve been working my way through the books of David Sedaris. Feckin hilarious.

  14. Kate says:

    Well after reading those I don’t think I’ll bother – if it doesn’t ‘get me’ in the first 3 pages I lose heart!!

  15. English Mum says:

    Sandra: Thanks! Been having great fun with all the cooking (and eating, natch!). Yeh, I’m a failure, I just couldn’t force myself to persevere. I mean, the whole point of a book club is that you push the boundaries a bit and read books that are a bit out of your comfort zone, but oh, I dunno… x

    Jay: Well at least you tried. Actually, I have a pristine copy if you still want to read it ;)

    Tara: Yeah, maybe we should go with that one. Glad you agreed and it wasn’t just me not putting the work in!

    Roy: Urm, well this was certainly not manly LOL! I guess you get through a few audiobooks on your taxi travels? Any you’d recommend?

    Wee One: Forgiven. Ooh, someone’s just given me a book by him – must have been me Ma. Will give it a go x

    Kate: Me too, I think that’s my trouble. Except with me it happens if someone hasn’t been horribly mutilated or creatively murdered quite early on x

  16. Tom says:

    If it’s “blood and murders and forensic teams and autopsies” you’re looking for, I just finished The Black Dahlia Files by Donald Wolfe in 3 days.

    I, too, have several started but unfinished books on the bedside.

  17. English Mum says:

    Tom: Welcome! Excellent, I’m off to look for it on Ebay as we speak. Many thanks x

Leave a Reply

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Copyright 2008 - 2009 English Mum | Powered by Wordpress | Designed by ADD Creative