Downer

Well, dear reader, I’ve upset someone. I received a very strong message from someone who said, and I quote:

“this is a DIFFERENT country to Britain and it has a different history, a different culture, and indeed a different language, which does not ‘mispronounce’? or mis-spell names but has a different linguistic root to English and therefore does not follow the rules of English phonetics…as you say ‘go figure’?…ie get an Irish - English dictionary and find out that all the apparently ‘meaningless’? names all mean something quite specific in the nations original language”.

Right, now I’m bloody cross. What I would say is this: firstly, I would never, ever be intentionally patronising or insulting to the Irish culture (in fact, I’m always pointing out how damned NICE Irish people are), and am painfully aware of how much of an outsider I am. I DO have an Irish-English dictionary thank you very much and am very much enjoying trying to learn Irish with the help of my sons who are learning it at school. I am also reading Irish history (give me a chance, I’ve been here two months), and am very respectful of the religion, culture, law and values of this lovely country (and every other country) where I consider myself to be a welcome guest. I’ve no idea where on this blog I’ve said that any Irish words are ‘mispronounced or mis-spelled’ but if the gentleman would like to point this out, I’ll happily print a retraction. If my own personal struggle with the pronunciation of the word ‘Baroimhe’ offends him then he should feel free to look away - frankly it embarrasses the hell out of me.

My wonderful, kind, funny, sweet and permanently cheerful Irish friend, J, reads my blog and has never, to my knowledge, found anything to be patronising or demeaning, and I’m sure she’d tell me if she did. If I find Irish a confusing language, aren’t I allowed to comment to that effect (on my own blog) and aren’t I to be commended for perseverance in continuing to try and learn?

Furthermore, my husband is Irish, and I’m sure he’d slap me around the head should I ever get too big for my boots on this crappy little website that has, on average, a whopping TWELVE (count them) hits per day.

Finally I would say, with respect, that this IS supposed to be a humorous diary for my friends back home.

And with that, I’m afraid, I’ve lost the ability to write anything funny. ‘Go figure’.

__________________________________________________________________________

Edited to include: please take a min to read the lovely comment below - it’s rather - er - pertinent to this gentleman ;)

No Responses

  1. jennynib Says:

    Silly girl for giving credence to this diatribe!

    I believe your comment, which I found absolutely Hilarious, stemmed from a mispronunciation of a local placename. I was in Wales recently, and commented on the impossibility of pronouncing anything! Did my hosts rebuke me for my nationalist insensitivity? No! Why? Because it would have been bloody rude!

    Commenting as an Irish speaker, whose son attends an Irish speaking school, and who is from a long line of passionate Irish speakers, your blog is sensitive, extremely well written, roaringly funny and definately respectful. In fact, the only thing you ‘poke fun’ of is yourself, and the unfamiliar situations you find yourself in. Would your critic, finding himself in Middle England writing a similar blog on a similar subject find himself subject to this criticism? I don’t think so!

    If our pedantic friend has so much time on his hands, I suggest he engages in something a little more meaningful and less bitter. Charity work, perhaps, or long breezy walks off short piers…

    Chin up, the only bad thing about your blog is that (tut, tut) you don’t update it often enough for me!

    Sort that out please Missus!!

  2. Administrator Says:

    Why thank you, darling. It’s people like you that make Ireland the place that I now love to call home. Mwah xx

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.